The second one looks better imo. Looks like it had more effort put into the design. As for improvements I think that it just needs more details to highlight the door. The current design for it is too repetitive and would work better for a chain of doors.
I knew miss's door design would win. It is infact alot more detailed than mine. I personally prefer simple designs that look rather detailed at the same time like the one you see above. Not saying miss's design is bad, its stunning! just not my style.
Comments
The other seems too grand and tall for me...