Danmachi has won the Ram Kennel! Next up is a Wuvva Pig Kennel!

ALL items Stack-able?

BJDwareBJDware Down underRetired Moderator
edited January 2017 in Suggestions & Comments 105.65 Karma

Yes, yet another suggestion...

I Propose that ALL the same items should stack within a single slot.
A lot of items require the use of one full slot within the inventory or chest and do not stack. I Do not see as to why that is so, and why it should remain as so.

Eg:
image

It is a very big pain to store or transport such items that require a whole slot for just one item, instead of stacking.

Items that do not stack:
-any vanity item ( hats, cloaks etc )
-Stamps
-Kennels
-Wands
-Sentries
-Unused rooms/realms of the same size & type
-Doorways (unused)
-Clanstones
-... What else am i missing?

Alternative suggestions by posters:
- Compressed Chest (or sentry) where you can stack any items in that chest :)
- Transportable Chest (or sentry) a chest where when you grab will not pop the items out that are inside it.

What do you think about this?
Feel free to comment below.





The Poll:
  1. Should all items stack?56 votes
    1. Yes! Storage/transportation is important!
      57.14%
    2. No! Dispenser setup is important etc, i like things as they are.
      19.64%
    3. Maybe! Maybe some things should stack, but not all.
      23.21%
    4. Fence sitter. I Have no opinion.
        0.00%
«1

Comments

  • 8.65 Karma
    This should be added... My inventory gets clogged out too much by items of the same kind ;-;
  • QuackersQuackers Member
    14.40 Karma
    +1 needed for me to be organized even better than my current state :P
  • MiwkyMiwky at your house stealing your Peanut butter jarMember
    49.10 Karma
    another great suggestion coming from BJD
    I'm sure most of us have thought of this but never was suggested.
  • Reaper BearReaper Bear USAMember
    8.00 Karma
    +1 *thumbs up*
  • 007Awesome007007Awesome007 Member
    10.85 Karma
    +1

    I don't think Clanstones can be stacked either.
  • 4.00 Karma
    agreed
  • BJDwareBJDware Down underRetired Moderator
    105.65 Karma

    I don't think Clanstones can be stacked either.

    Added.
  • piouspious Member
    edited January 2017 22.40 Karma
    Would save me a lot of space here:
    image
    Thumbs up on this one.

    Other things that are unstackable include Plasms and Dehydrated Cubes, but both items have good reasons not to be stackable. I believe Nametags aren't stackable, although I'm not certain on that.

    I keep coming back to edit this... I propose a feature by which you can toggle whether or not you'd like hats and other attire stack or not. For the reason stated in the comment below this. Some would just prefer a conventional means.

    - Sidenote, trying to get this image to actually show up as an image through my phone was a painful process.
  • 73.50 Karma
    But then imagine running shops with clothing items... You would spend alot of time making non-stacked clothings.
  • BJDwareBJDware Down underRetired Moderator
    105.65 Karma

    But then imagine running shops with clothing items... You would spend alot of time making non-stacked clothings.

    But alas, you will be able to access and store them easier in a shop. Just separate one per sale.
  • RawSkinRawSkin Member
    4.55 Karma
    1+!!!
    Ware, did you go to a mountain in Japan and meditate for 20 years to gain KNOWLEDGE!?
    Where did all these ideas come from?
    Good job though
  • Elemental godElemental god The netherlandsMember
    261.00 Karma
    Yes pls +1 i dont really have this problem but it would be better for other players (and if i ever get this problem too :P)
  •  gdog gdog Forum Moderator, Game Moderator
    80.80 Karma
    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.
  • StevenlolStevenlol Member
    69.00 Karma
    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.

    lol, yeah
    There's often these hollas
  • edited January 2017 85.75 Karma
    I would also say no for another reason. Having certain items not stackable makes it easier to do giveaways for example prize machines. If they were stackable then we would have.to break the stacks if we wanted to stagger the prizes. As a person who was the first in charge of keeping Hinter's amusement park prize dispensers in stock I can tell you what a pain it was to have to break apart stacks. Breaking apart stacks I would have to type in the amount each time which was not pleasant. It is less of hassle of hauling an x amount and throwing it in my opinion.

    I see the benefits of this suggestion but I feel it carries more cons than pros. I do feel though that certain things would benefit like sentries and door stamps but stay away from clothing and environment stamps as an example. Maybe have a community poll to see what needs to be stackable.
  • RawSkinRawSkin Member
    4.55 Karma
    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.

    To battle the halp halp I dropped in lobay issue. There should be a confirmation when dropping an item. Easy fix

  • Elemental godElemental god The netherlandsMember
    261.00 Karma
    RawSkin said:

    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.

    To battle the halp halp I dropped in lobay issue. There should be a confirmation when dropping an item. Easy fix

    Pls no! What if you have to drop like 20 different items in a prize machine ;_;
  • StevenlolStevenlol Member
    69.00 Karma
    RawSkin said:

    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.

    To battle the halp halp I dropped in lobay issue. There should be a confirmation when dropping an item. Easy fix

    Yes! I sometimes accidentally drop items when playing on my phone.. Good thing I pick it up in time.
  • cubic'dcubic'd Member
    5.85 Karma
    -1
    these kind of items should not be stackable
  • Jerrynana123Jerrynana123 Member
    edited January 2017 27.30 Karma
    Sorry, -1
    Just, Should not be stackable.
    It doesn't make any sense.
  • Sir John GreySir John Grey Member
    31.35 Karma
    I suggest to make a chest that make all items stackable instead :)
  • KewbinKewbin Member
    11.35 Karma
    @BJDware just tell me, how can you wear 3000 Feather Hats at once ;) It has to be uncomfortable.
  • RootbeerrRootbeerr Member
    40.45 Karma
    RawSkin said:

    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    They are valuable they should all have their own slot or it'll just be another thing I have a random number stack of.

    To battle the halp halp I dropped in lobay issue. There should be a confirmation when dropping an item. Easy fix

    No offense, but a conformation drop screen is a terrible idea. First of all, most people drop stuff in lobby's on purpose, and second of all most people drop things A LOT and its would just be annoying.



  • BJDwareBJDware Down underRetired Moderator
    edited January 2017 105.65 Karma
    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    It is another issue altogether, that may require a separate suggestion.
    Shouldn't factor in on this suggestion.

    Eg.
    -Item cannot be picked up by another player for x amount of time.
    -If player leaves, logs out etc, and the item is unclaimed, said item will return to the players inventory.

    etc etc.
    Another issue entirely.

    Sorry, -1
    Just, Should not be stackable.
    It doesn't make any sense.

    And stacking 20,000 dirt does? :P

    @BJDware just tell me, how can you wear 3000 Feather Hats at once ;) It has to be uncomfortable.

    Why 3k? Lets do 5k >:D
    But i see where your going with that, and it would be a very simple fix.



    So far its all Storage/transportation VS Dispenser setup.
    Which is more important? I Think i'll add a poll to decide.

  • 85.75 Karma
    With the large majority voting Maybe some things should stack including myself having chosen that option, another poll will be need to implemented after a set period of time has elapsed to further narrow down what individuals opinions are.
  • SnowiezSnowiez Member
    4.40 Karma
    YES!!! TOTALLY needs to be added!! +1
  • Jerrynana123Jerrynana123 Member
    27.30 Karma
    BJDware said:

    gdog said:

    "Help GODOG!!! I jus dropped 58 Romans in a lobbay and I DC'd, Halp Halp HALP I CRI"

    This is why -1
    lol

    It is another issue altogether, that may require a separate suggestion.
    Shouldn't factor in on this suggestion.

    Eg.
    -Item cannot be picked up by another player for x amount of time.
    -If player leaves, logs out etc, and the item is unclaimed, said item will return to the players inventory.

    etc etc.
    Another issue entirely.

    Sorry, -1
    Just, Should not be stackable.
    It doesn't make any sense.

    And stacking 20,000 dirt does? :P

    @BJDware just tell me, how can you wear 3000 Feather Hats at once ;) It has to be uncomfortable.

    Why 3k? Lets do 5k >:D
    But i see where your going with that, and it would be a very simple fix.



    So far its all Storage/transportation VS Dispenser setup.
    Which is more important? I Think i'll add a poll to decide.

    I had a reason in my mind. But being a goldfish and forgets everything in a few seconds I forgot. And also, Wait. What was I going to say?
  • Kawaii.CoolzKawaii.Coolz Member
    5.95 Karma
    omg totally YES thats a GREAT idea!!!!!! I accidently tapped over my food deco and it disappeared after paying 150c!!!!!!!!!!!! Also, YES identical clothes SHOULD be added in the same slot!!!
  • BJDwareBJDware Down underRetired Moderator
    105.65 Karma
    Interesting poll results thus far, but alas, only 14 voters. Be sure to get your vote in :)

    With the large majority voting Maybe some things should stack including myself having chosen that option, another poll will be need to implemented after a set period of time has elapsed to further narrow down what individuals opinions are.

    Give it time. Things are swinging in another direction now. It may change.
  • piouspious Member
    22.40 Karma
    I'd +1 in your poll if iOS users weren't so limited in the forums.
Sign In or Register to comment.